Similarities between the scottsboro boys and tom robinson. Many local newspapers had made their conclusions about the defendants before the trials began. Whats the different between scottsboro trials and the to. The scottsboro boys trial controversial court cases can both tear communities apart and shape our history for the better. The transcript of the trial left the supreme court with no other choice but to throw out the convictions.
The scottsboro boys were nine african american teenagers, ages to 19, falsely accused in alabama of raping two white women on a train in 1931. As in scottsboro, mockingbird concerns the allegations of the rape of a white woman by a black man, a crime punishable by death penalty in alabama at the time. Norris one of the scottsboro boys was the first black to stand on trial at the jackson county grand jury. The scottsboro boys trials were in front of a biased allwhite jury and audience, making it extremely difficult, if not impossible, for the chance of them winning the trials. The scottsboro trials racism wasted the lives of nine young, black men. Justice felix frankfurter said at the time that the ruling was the first application of the limitations of the fourteenth amendment to a state criminal trial. The trial of the ninth one roy wright the youngest 12 or years old ended in a mistrial when some jurors held. Published on january 23, 1936 it takes courage to do the right thing in the face of public clamor for the wrong thing, but when justice is not administered fairly. Exhibitview is the premier and userfriendly trial presentation software. Nine young black alabama youths ranging in age from 12 to 19.
The trials led to two influential supreme court decisions, affirming rights that we regard as fundamental today. Although different in many ways, the scopes trial of 1925 and the scottsboro trials of the 1930s both captured. In 1932, arguing before the supreme court on behalf of one of the scottsboro boys in powell v. Over the course of the two decades that followed, the struggle for justice of the scottsboro boys, as the black teens were called, made celebrities out of anonymities, launched and ended careers, wasted lives, produced heroes, opened southern juries to blacks, exacerbated sectional strife, and divided americas political left. Olen montgomery, clarence norris, willie roberson front, andrew wright partially obscured, ozie powell, eugene williams, charley weems and roy wright. The case went to the united states supreme court in 1937, and the lives of the nine were saved, though it was almost twenty years before the last defendant was freed from prison. The court, 7 2, ruled that the right of the defendants under the. The scottsboro boys cases, as they became known, focused an international spotlight on jim crow in america in the 1930s and stirred demands for racial justice in the u.
The case went to the united states supreme court in 1937, and the lives of the nine were saved, though it was almost 20 years before the last defendant was freed from prison. During the scottsboro boys third trial, judge william callahan took over for judge horton. There are many similarities between the scottsboro trial and the trial of tom robinson in the novel, to kill a mockingbird. Horton was praised by the prosecution and defense alike when he was named to judge the second trial of the scottsboro defendants in decatur, alabama. Lees novel took this case and created the fictional case of tom robinson, a black man accused of raping a lower class white girl in a small town in alabama during the depressionera. The story of the scottsboro boys does not fit an easy narrative arc. The second round of trials began in the circuit court in decatur, alabama, 50 miles west of scottsboro, under judge james horton. The scottsboro trial in the 1930s, the story of the scottsboro boys, nine black teenagers accused of raping two white women on a train in alabama, was reported in newspapers around the world.
Olen montgomery, ozie powell, willie roberson, eugene williams and andy wright are tried, convicted, and sentenced to death. The cases included a lynch mob before the suspects had been indicted, allwhite juries, rushed trials, and disruptive mobs. In front of the federal supreme court, leibowitz argued that the case had been sealed by the fact that the boys had been tried by an all white jury, a clear violation of the constitutional right to trial by peers. The cases came at a turning point in american justice. There were some successes in the form of provisions for bilingual education and affirmative action programs. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Scottsboro case sparked the interracial movement for.
The case was given to a vibrant communist lawyer by the name of samuel leibowitz. Scottsboro boy roy wright, age, testifying in the first trial i was sitting in a chair and one of those girls was testifying. In a trial where the only plausible evidence proved their innocence, they were still convicted. The scottsboro rape case was not merely one of americas most prominent. Pattersons second trial began on march 30, 1933, in judge james hortons courtroom. The trial of the scottsboro boys is perhaps one of the proudest moments of american radicalism, in which a mass movement of blacks and whitesled by communists and radicalssuccessfully beat the jim crow legal system. During the 1940s, he was appointed to serve a 14year term as a justice of the kings county court, then the principal trial court for criminal matters in. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. The jury in robinsons trial comprises poor white residents of old sarum. The office of international information programs of the u. After the initial trials sentence to death by execution april 9th, 1932 execution of william hokes was the next day naacp chose not to get involved for awhile the communist party represented them at the supreme court in 1932, supreme court declared the 14th amendment had been violated, but only some were granted a retrial 7.
All of this was going on during the great depression. Bridges, a scottsboro physician, was too ill to come to court, but he testified before judge james e. The best trial presentation program does all these things and more. Scottsboro trial political science flashcards quizlet. Scottsboro boys trials 19311937 no crime in american history let alone a crime that never occurred produced as many trials, convictions, reversals, and retrials as did an alleged gang rape of two white girls by nine black teenagers on the southern railroad freight run from chattanooga to.
Trials of the scottsboro boys began twelve days after their arrest in the courtroom of judge a. Haywood patterson described the scene as one big smiling white face. Scottsboro trial defendants encyclopedia of alabama. Scottsboro boys trial and defense campaign 19311937. Haywood patterson goodman, 6 i saw all of them have intercourse. Between april 79,1931, eight of the scottsboro boys were sentenced to death. Social welfare history project scottsboro boys, trial and. Litigation support services provided are hot seat operators, trial techs, trial technology, video depositions and legal videographers serving alabama, florida, georgia, mississippi and tennessee. Changing america and the changing image of scottsboro jstor. It provides attorneys an impressive and easy to use software program that gives them the best chance to prevail in court. The best trial presentation software needs to have instant document and deposition retrieval, and instant video playback.
Early in trial, leibowitz negotiated a plea bargain under which irwin avoided the death penalty but would remain in custody for the rest of his life. Pending an appeal to the alabama supreme court, the executions of the nine defendants are stayed. Courtroom television network now available on video. The scottsboro trial travesty of justice slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. Aclu lawyers played a major role in the infamous scottsboro boys case, which began in 1931 and would ultimately have farreaching effects. The scottsboro boys were nine black teenagers falsely accused of raping two white women aboard a train near scottsboro, alabama, in 1931. The nine, after nearly being lynched, were brought to trial in scottsboro in april 1931, just three weeks after their arrests. Scottsboro trial history of the scottsboro boys, things. The case marked the first stirrings of the civil rights movement and led to two landmark supreme court rulings that established important rights for criminal defendants. Scottsboro boys case facts legal world and childhood. The defendants in the scottboro trial and their lawyer, samuel leibowitz, at a decatur jail. Scottsboro trial defendantsthe saga began on march 25, 1931, when a fight broke out between groups of young black and white passengers riding a freight train through jackson county. Ruby bates confessed the charge of raped was false. His lean, lanky physical appearance was often compared to lincolns, and he was considered extremely fairminded.
Take a look at these 10 controversial court cases in the u. On the request of the state, they were tried in three groups in scottsboro this is why it is known as scottsboro boys case. Scottsboro case helped redefine rape the clayman institute for. Excerpt from scottsboro case goes to the juryreprinted from the new york times. Horton at one of pattersons earlier trials that the womans pulse and breathing were normal and that her body showed no sign of cuts and bruises with which she testified at this trial that she was covered. The scottsboro judges american experience official. The first juries in the scottsboro trials failed to include any african americans, a situation that caused the u. But when the supreme court rejects the decision, the case is sent back to alabama where it is retried under judge horton arthur hill.
Scottsboro boys, trial and defense campaign 19311937 in. Scottsboro trial defendants the defendants in the scottboro trial and their lawyer, samuel leibowitz, at a decatur jail. Eighth grade lesson the scottsboro trial betterlesson. For example, there is only one person on trial in the novel and he is a grown man with a. The scottsboro boys were nine africanamerican teens who were each tried and convicted of raping two white women on a southern railroad freight train.
The twenty years that it took for the scottsboro case to be wrung from the judicial system. In november, 1932, the united states supreme court ordered a second trial on the grounds that the men had been inadequately defended in court. After the quiz, i explain to my students that today i am going to introduce them to the reallife case that inspired the tom robinson case in to kill a mockingbird. After it returned its first verdicts, a brass band outside the courtroom. This book uses primary source documents to show the backgr. Also as in scottsboro, one major problem in tom robinsons trial is that the jury is racially biased. The white boys were forced from the train and wired ahead to the next stop on the line to have the black youths apprehended. Many believe the highprofile series of events was an.
Atv, presented on july 11, 1972, a fiftytwo minute program on the scottsboro case. But in a precedentsetting ruling, the supreme court found that the defense provided the scottsboro youths was incompetent and ordered a new trial. The trial of the scottsboro boys was a world renowned case in the 1930s in which nine black youths were accused of raping to white girls in alabama. They were accused of rape, but all it was was an accusation.
Alabama, pollak used the same legal strategy to establishthat due process prohibits the states from sentencing someone to death without ensuring that the defendant has been adequately represented by a lawyer at trial. The trial aspect of tkm is loosely related to the scottsboro boys. The trial of the scottsboro boys is perhaps one of the proudest moments of american radicalism, in which a mass movement of blacks and whitesled by communists and radicalssuccessfully beat the jim crow. Courtroom technologies is a birmingham alabama based trial presentation trial technology company. The trials of the scottsboro boys by douglas linder ssrn. Famous trials first appeared on the web in 1995, making this site older than about 99. There are many parallels between the scottsboro cases and to kill a mockingbird. One of the boys accusers, ruby bates, recanted her initial testimony and agreed to testify for the defense. The landmark set of legal cases from this incident dealt with racism and the right to a fair trial. In april 1933, an anxious nation watched ruby bates walk through the door of an alabama courtroom. On april 3, victoria price was called to the stand with a short direct examination of 16 minutes, where she told her story of going to chattanooga to look for jobs, the fight on the train between the group of whites and blacks, and the rape patterson was a part of.
The scottsboro boys and fundamental rights by david pitts this year is the 70th anniversary of a trial that captured the imagination of the nation for almost two decades. Although ruby bates testified at the second trial that the rape story had been invented by victoria price and the crime had not taken place, the men were once again. Bridges says that price showed very little physical signs of. Department of state provides products and services that explain u.
1339 468 719 1171 1344 1460 720 329 949 685 1414 470 421 1060 1105 1532 95 1341 44 621 495 687 1499 589 916 300 699 1264 768 752 639 1417 599 1243 219 1476